POL S 302 A: Free Will, Nature, and Nurture in Politics and Society

Autumn 2025
Meeting:
TTh 2:30pm - 4:20pm
SLN:
20702
Section Type:
Lecture
POL S MAJORS: COUNTS FOR FIELD A, POLITICAL THEORY
Syllabus Description (from Canvas):

You can find the full syllabus here

Smith's grading scale here

First midterm exam study guide here

Second midterm exam study guide here

 

September 25  Free will, nature, and nurture in political science and other disciplines (slides)

Read/listen/watch: 

Closer to Truth, The Big Questions in Free Will (2016), watch

 

September 30  Free will in Western philosophy (slides)

Read/listen/watch: 

Julian Baggini, Do We Have Free Will? (2015), listen or watch

Paul Bloom, The War on Reason (2014), read

Robert Sapolsky, The Biology of Humans at Our Best and Worst (2018), watchLinks to an external site.

Rush, lyrics to Freewill, read

 

October 2  Religious ideas, determinism, and free will (slides)

(One of the original readings from the syllabus has been removed from the list below.)

Read/listen/watch: 

Jayaram V, Perspectives on What Karma Means (2021), read

Jane Dempsey Douglass, Predestination (1985), read

WhyIslam, Concept of God in Islam (2014), read

 

October 3  Acknowledgment of course policies due, 8:00 PM

 

October 7  Free will and moral responsibility (slides)

Read/listen/watch: 

Adrian Raine, Making a Murderer (2021), watch

Paul Bloom, Natural Born Killers (2013), read

Michael Shermer, Free Will and Moral Responsibility in a Secular Society (2014), watch

Stephen Cave, There’s No Such Thing as Free Will (2016), read

 

October 9  Free will in political science:  structure and agency (slides)

Read/listen/watch: 

Raj Chatty, Improving Equality of Opportunity (2019), watch

Tage Rai, How Could They? (2015), read

Brian Klaas, Fluke: Chance, Chaos, and Why Everything We Do Matters, LSE event (2024), watchLinks to an external site.

 

October 14  Nature and evolutionary psychology (slides)

Read/listen/watch:  

Frans de Waal, Moral Behavior in Animals (2012), watch

Leda Cosmides and John Tooby, The Mind Is Not a Blank Slate (2015), watch

Cristine Legare, Why Social Science Needs Evolutionary Theory (2018), read

Laith Al-Shawaf, Seven Key Misconceptions about Evolutionary Psychology (2019), read

Laith Al-Shawaf, Evolutionary Psychology:  Predictively Powerful or Just-So Stories? (2020), read

 

October 16 Midterm exam #1

 

October 21  Nurture and cultural anthropology (slides)

Read/listen/watch:

Kwame Anthony Appiah, Honor and Moral Revolutions (2014), watch

Whet Moser, American Violence and Southern Culture (2012), read

Michele Gelfand, Understanding the Cultural Codes that Drive Behavior (2019), watchLinks to an external site.

Pew Research Center, What’s Morally Acceptable (2014), read

The Economist, The Japanese Art of Child-Rearing (2024), read

 

October 23  Nature and nurture: reconciling evolutionary psychology and cultural anthropology (slides)

Read/listen/watch:  

Susan Clancy, Abducted: How People Come to Believe They Were Abducted by Aliens, (2016), watch

Hidden Brain, Olympic Victory and Defeat (2016), listen

Alison Gopnik, The Gardener and the Carpenter, talk at Google (2016), watch

Rebecca Saxe, How We Read Each Other’s Minds (2009), watch

 

October 28  Nature and nurture in behavioral genetics, part I (slides)

Read/listen/watch:

Robert Plomin, How DNA Makes Us Who We Are (2019), watch

Gideon Lewis-Kraus, Can Progressives Be Convinced that Genetics Matters? (2021), read here, or here if you hit the paywall

 

October 30  Nature and nurture in behavioral genetics, part II (slides)

Read/listen/watch:  

Freddie deBoer, Individual Genetics, Group Environments (2020), read

Ed Yong, A Waste of 1,000 Research papers (2019), read here or here if you hit the paywall

Nancy Segal, Twin Misconceptions (2017), listen or watch

Gretchen Reynolds, One Twin Exercises, The Other Doesn’t (2015), read

 

November 4  Group identity and politics (slides)

Read/listen/watch:  

Laurie Santos, The Roots of Racism in Rhesus Monkeys (2011), watch

Seth Andrews, Let’s Not Wake Up Like This (2019), watch

Thomas Edsall, America, We Have a Problem (2020), read, or here if you hit the paywall 

 

November 6  Political attitudes and behaviors, part I (slides)

Read/listen/watch:  

Robert Kurzban, Why Everybody (Else) Is a Hypocrite, talk at The Amazing Meeting (2014), watch

Hannah Holmes, Red Brain, Blue Brain (2014), watch

John Hibbing, Liberals and Conservatives:  The Biology of Political Differences (2019), watch

Christopher Federico, The Psychology of Political Behavior (2019), listen

 

November 11 No class (Veterans' Day)

 

November 13 Midterm exam #2

 

November 18  Political attitudes and behaviors, part II (slides)

Read/listen/watch: 

Glenn Wilson, The Psychology of Politics (2012), watch

Shadi Hamid, How Politics Replaced Religion in America (2021), read, or here if you hit the paywall

David Pinsof, The Alliance Theory of Political Belief Systems (2024), listenLinks to an external site.

 

November 20  Political attitudes and behaviors, part III (slides)

Read/listen/watch:  

Roy Baumeister, Do You Really Have Free Will? (2013), read, or here if you hit the paywall

Julia Galef, Soldiers and Scouts:  Why Our Minds Weren’t Built for Truth, talk at Long Now Foundation (2019), just the first 50:45 (watchLinks to an external site.)

 

November 25  Nature and nurture in religion (slides)

Read/listen/watch: 

Justin L. Barrett, The Naturalness of Religion (2011), listen

Ara Norenzayan, The Idea that Launched a Thousand Civilizations (2012), read

Kristin Laurin, Belief in God:  A Cultural Adaptation with Important Side Effects (2017), read

Azim Shariff, Psychological and Social Consequences of Religious (Dis)belief (2015), watch

 

December 2  Nature and nurture in sex and gender (slides)

Read/listen/watch:

The Economist, The Perils of Polygamy, 2017, read

Scott Barry Kaufman, Taking Sex Differences in Personality Seriously (2019), read

Judith Butler, Your Behavior Creates Your Gender (2011), watch

wikipedia entry on fa'afafine, read

 

December 4  The political and policy implications of beliefs about free will, nature, and nurture (slides)

Read/listen/watch:  

Elizabeth Suhay, The Political Science of Genetic Explanations (2018), listen

Discovery Institute, The Wedge Document (1998), read

J. P. Moreland, Neuroscience and the Soul (2013), watch

Robert Frank, Before Tea, Thank Your Lucky Stars (2009), read

Jonah Goldberg, It's Just a Pun, People (2025), read

 

December 9  Final exam, 4:30-6:20

Catalog Description:
Examines beliefs and actions in politics and other domains from the standpoint of free will, nature, and nurture. Compares political science to other disciplines in explaining why people think and act as they do.
Department Requirements Met:
Political Theory Field
GE Requirements Met:
Social Sciences (SSc)
Credits:
5.0
Status:
Active
Last updated:
December 6, 2025 - 4:07 pm